All guides

Eligibility denials: what CARC 27, 31 and 26 mean for a clinic

A claim denied with CARC 27 means the payer says the care happened after coverage ended. CARC 31 means the payer could not match the patient to a member. Both usually trace back to an eligibility check that was missed, stale or mistyped. This guide covers what these codes say, what they do not say, and what to look at first.

What is a CARC?

CARC stands for claim adjustment reason code. A payer sends it on the electronic remittance advice (the 835) to explain why it paid less than you billed, or nothing at all. The code list is published by X12, the standards body, and you can read the full X12 claim adjustment reason code list on its site.

Each code has an official description and a start date. Your payer adds a group code (such as CO or PR) that signals who is responsible for the amount. Group codes vary by payer and situation, so check the remittance and the payer’s policy rather than assuming.

Which codes are about eligibility?

These are the codes tied to eligibility. The wording below is quoted from the X12 list, which shows each as active with no stop date at the time of writing.

Code X12 description
26 “Expenses incurred prior to coverage.”
27 “Expenses incurred after coverage terminated.”
31 “Patient cannot be identified as our insured.”
32 “Our records indicate the patient is not an eligible dependent.”
33 “Insured has no dependent coverage.”
140 “Patient/Insured health identification number and name do not match.”
177 “Patient has not met the required eligibility requirements.”

X12 lists codes 26, 27, 31, 32 and 33 as starting on January 1, 1995, so these are long-standing codes, not new ones.

From eligibility denial to next step
  1. 1Read the code on the 835
  2. 2Compare to the check on file
  3. 3Re-verify with the payer
  4. 4Fix the record or bill the right party
  5. 5Note the cause

Illustrative routine, not a payer requirement.

What does CARC 27 mean?

CARC 27 says the expenses were incurred after coverage terminated. It compares the date of service to a coverage end date in the payer’s records.

When the payer denies for this reason, the X12 guidance for the 835 says the claim should carry a coverage expiration date. In an X12 interpretation, the implementation guide’s rule for that date segment reads: “Required when payment is denied because of expiration of coverage.” So on a true denial you can often see the date the payer believes coverage ended. That date is your first clue.

Things to check:

  • Was eligibility checked on the date of service, or days earlier?
  • Did the patient say anything about a job change, a lapsed premium or a new plan?
  • Does the end date on the remittance match what the patient’s card or the payer’s portal shows now?
  • Could the payer’s record be wrong? If so, ask the payer to review it.

A reversal can repeat the code. The same X12 interpretation describes a claim first denied with CARC 27, then paid after the member record was corrected. The later reversal repeated the code, but no coverage expiration date was sent. X12 said that follows the rules, because a reversal is not itself a denial for expired coverage. The practical lesson is to read the whole remittance, not just the code, before you decide a claim is lost again.

What does CARC 31 mean?

CARC 31 says the payer could not identify the patient as its insured. This is a matching problem, not a date problem. The payer looked for the member and did not find one.

Common first checks, none of which are rules from the code itself:

  • Name spelled as on the card, including suffixes and hyphens.
  • Date of birth.
  • Member ID typed with the right prefix and no swapped characters.
  • Whether the patient is the subscriber or a dependent, and who the subscriber is.
  • Whether the card is from the payer you billed.

CARC 140 is a close cousin. X12 describes it as the health identification number and name not matching. If you see 31 or 140, compare the claim to the card first. CARC 177 (“Patient has not met the required eligibility requirements.”) is broader, so ask the payer which requirement it means.

What about 26, 32 and 33?

CARC 26 is the mirror of 27: the service happened before coverage began. This can happen near a plan start date, such as after open enrollment. Our checklist on re-verifying insurance after open enrollment covers that season.

CARC 32 and 33 are about dependents. One says the patient is not an eligible dependent in the payer’s records. The other says the insured has no dependent coverage. Both call for a conversation with the subscriber or the payer about who is actually on the plan.

How can a clinic prevent these denials?

Prevention is mostly about the check that happens before the visit. A short routine:

  1. Verify eligibility close to the date of service, not only at scheduling. Our guide to the insurance verification process lists the steps.
  2. Save the response with the date and time. A 271 eligibility response shows the coverage dates the payer reported.
  3. Scan the card, front and back, and compare the name and ID to the registration.
  4. Ask at every visit whether anything about coverage has changed.
  5. When another plan may exist, review coordination of benefits.
  6. Track denials by code, so you can see whether 27, 31 or 26 is the pattern.

Timely filing limits differ by payer and contract. If a patient’s coverage is in question, find out the payer’s filing and appeal deadlines early, so a fix does not come too late.

What should staff do after the denial arrives?

Work the denial in this order:

  1. Read the full remittance, including group code and any dates.
  2. Pull the eligibility response you saved for that date of service.
  3. If it shows coverage and the payer says otherwise, call the payer, ask for the reason in writing and request a review.
  4. If coverage had truly ended, find out whether the patient has new coverage and whether the claim can go to that payer.
  5. If the cause was a typing error, correct the claim and resubmit according to the payer’s instructions.
  6. Record what happened so the front desk can change the routine.

Whether the patient can be billed for an amount depends on your contracts, the payer and state law. Ask your billing lead or counsel before you send a patient a bill.

Where Clinicrung fits

Clinicrung is being built to run eligibility checks before visits and flag coverage that is ending or unclear, with a person reviewing anything doubtful. It is not built yet, and early access is delivered in small groups, partly by hand. Start your free trial.

This post is general information about claim denials and eligibility, not legal, billing or compliance advice. Payer rules vary and change, so confirm details with each payer and ask a qualified professional about your situation.