Good faith estimates for self-pay patients: a front desk guide
A good faith estimate is a written estimate of what care will cost. Under the No Surprises Act, health care providers and facilities must give one to uninsured or self-pay patients, either when the visit is scheduled or when the patient asks. This guide explains the rule in plain terms, based on CMS’s 2022 training material and fact sheet, so your front desk knows when to start the clock. Check CMS’s No Surprises Act pages for updates.
Which patients get a good faith estimate?
CMS’s training material says a consumer is generally considered uninsured or self-pay if they do not have health insurance, or if they plan not to use their plan or coverage to pay for some or all of the costs of the item or service.
That gives you two kinds of patients:
- Patients with no coverage at all.
- Patients who have coverage but choose not to bill it for this service.
There is an exclusion. The same CMS material says enrollees in federal health care programs, such as Medicaid, Medicare or TRICARE, are not eligible to receive a good faith estimate, because those programs have other surprise billing protections.
Patients who have insurance and plan to file a claim are handled differently. As of CMS’s 2022 material, they will be able to receive an advanced explanation of benefits from their plan, but the departments have deferred enforcement of that requirement until future rulemaking.
This is why insurance status has to be asked early. The CMS fact sheet on the interim final rule says providers and facilities must ask about insurance status when scheduling an item or service, or if requested by an individual.
How fast must the estimate be given?
The deadline depends on how far ahead the visit is booked. CMS’s training material gives two cases:
- If the patient schedules at least three business days before the service, the estimate is due no later than one business day after scheduling.
- If the patient schedules at least 10 business days (the longer window applies, even though the three-day case also fits) before the service, or asks for cost information without scheduling, the estimate is due no later than three business days after scheduling or asking.
- 3+ business days outEstimate due within 1 business day of booking
- 10+ business days outEstimate due within 3 business days of booking
- Cost question onlyEstimate due within 3 business days of the request
Business days, not calendar days. Check the rule text for cases not shown here.
Source cms.gov
The material does not spell out every case, such as a visit booked less than three business days out. If you handle same-week visits often, read the rule itself and ask your compliance advisor how it applies to you.
What goes in the estimate?
The CMS fact sheet says the estimate must cover expected charges for items or services reasonably expected to be provided together with the primary item or service. Its example is surgery, where the estimate might include the surgery, labs or tests, and anesthesia. Services scheduled separately, such as a pre-surgery appointment, are not included.
For a small clinic, that means the estimate is not just your own fee. It can involve other providers in the same episode of care. The April 2022 fact sheet says HHS would use enforcement discretion in 2022 for estimates that left out charges from other providers or facilities. That was a temporary measure, so check CMS’s current guidance on co-provider charges before relying on it.
How do patients learn they can ask?
Posting matters as well as timing. CMS says consumers should find information about the availability of good faith estimates on the provider or facility’s website, and in the office or on site where they might schedule or ask about costs. If a patient asks about cost, the provider must tell them, in writing or orally, about requesting an estimate. The information must also be available in accessible formats and languages.
What happens if the bill is higher?
The estimate is not a bill. It shows the costs the provider expects. But it sets a benchmark.
CMS says that if a patient is billed at least $400 more than the good faith estimate for any provider or facility, they may be able to use the patient-provider dispute resolution process. The patient must start that process within 120 calendar days of the date on the original bill.
Source cms.gov
Before it gets that far, CMS suggests patients can contact the provider, ask for the bill to match the estimate, negotiate, or ask about financial assistance. A front desk that can explain the estimate calmly will resolve many of these early.
A simple front desk routine
This is a suggested routine, not a requirement. Adapt it to your clinic.
- 1Ask about insurance at booking
- 2Note self-pay or not billing insurance
- 3Log the date and time of booking
- 4Send the estimate before the due date
- 5Keep a copy in the chart
- Ask every time. Make the insurance question part of the booking script.
- Record the start date. The deadline runs from scheduling or from the request, so log both.
- Count business days. Use a calendar that skips weekends and holidays.
- Use a template. CMS publishes a sample notice of the uninsured patient’s right to a good faith estimate. Review it with your advisor before using it.
- Keep a copy. If a dispute comes later, you will want the estimate and the date you sent it.
- Update when plans change. If a patient later decides to bill insurance, note it in the file.
Where Clinicrung fits
Clinicrung is being built to take over repetitive front office checks, such as noting insurance status at booking and reminding staff when an estimate is due, while your staff handle exceptions and the judgment calls. Early access is open in small groups, and the first trials are delivered partly by hand. Start your free trial to see whether it fits your front desk. For related steps, see our guides to insurance verification and Medicaid eligibility checks.
This article is general information, not legal, medical or billing advice. Federal and state rules change and have exceptions, so check the current rule text and ask a qualified advisor about your clinic.