All guides

Peer-to-peer review after a prior authorization denial: a guide

A peer-to-peer review is a call between the clinician who ordered a service and a physician at the health plan who handled the denial. It gives the clinician a chance to explain the case and hear the plan’s reasoning. It is not the same as an appeal, and the window to ask for one can be very short, so the front office needs to know the rule before a denial arrives.

The details below come from two plans’ published policies. They are examples, not a standard. Every plan sets its own rules, so check the denial letter and the plan’s provider manual.

What is a peer-to-peer review?

The idea is the same across plans: a physician-level conversation about a denied request. How each plan defines it differs a little.

  • Blue Shield of California Promise, in its Medi-Cal peer-to-peer policy (UM-039), defines it as a physician-level review of medical records used to decide whether to uphold a denial.
  • Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan, in its guide to requesting a peer-to-peer review (revised January 2026), says the purpose is to exchange information about the clinical nuances of the member’s condition and the medical necessity of the services.

Both plans describe the call as physician to physician, with the treating or ordering clinician speaking for the practice. What staff can do is get the request in on time and prepare the file.

How long do you have to ask for one?

This is the part that catches clinics out. The two plans give very different windows, and they count days differently.

Plan and line of business Window Unit
Blue Shield of California Promise (Medi-Cal) 5 days from the initial decision Calendar days
Blue Care Network (BCN) commercial, Michigan (outpatient preservice) 7 days from the denial date Business days

The sources say it this way. Blue Shield Promise says the treating physician can speak directly with the responsible physician within five calendar days of the initial decision. Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan says a request for BCN commercial outpatient preservice services must be submitted within seven business days of the date the initial prior authorization request was denied.

Five calendar days can include a weekend. If the denial lands on a Thursday, there may be only two or three working days left to speak with the plan physician. That is why the date on the denial notice should go on a calendar the day it arrives.

A peer-to-peer request, step by step (example)
  1. 1Denial arrives
  2. 2Note the request window
  3. 3Clinician decides to ask
  4. 4Request sent the way the plan says
  5. 5Call with the plan physician
  6. 6Appeal if still unresolved

Illustrative. The order is a general pattern; each plan sets its own steps.

How do you request it?

The method depends on the plan. Two examples:

  • Blue Shield Promise: the treating physician calls the number given in the denial letter. The policy says the review will occur within one business day of receipt of the telephone request.
  • BCN commercial, Michigan: for outpatient preservice services, the practice completes a physician peer-to-peer request form and sends it by fax or email during business hours. Outreach does not happen until the next business day, and the reviews are scheduled on business days in set time blocks, Eastern time.

The same Michigan document also lists a separate fax process for Blue Cross commercial outpatient requests, so read the row for your plan. It says its process does not apply to requests denied by vendors that manage prior authorization for Blue Cross or BCN. That is a reminder to find out who actually made the decision. The company named on the denial letter is the place to start.

Does a peer-to-peer review change the decision?

Sometimes, but not always, and it depends on the plan.

So the call may end in a reversal, or it may only teach you what the plan wants to see. Either result is useful to write down.

Is it the same as an appeal?

No. The Michigan guide says you can submit an appeal without completing a peer-to-peer review. It also says that for Blue Cross commercial and BCN commercial, if you want a peer-to-peer review, you must request it before submitting a provider appeal. For Medicare Plus Blue, the same document’s timing table says the plan does not accept peer-to-peer requests and points to its two-level provider appeal process instead. Its other sections add detail, so read them for your service type.

The Blue Shield Promise policy says that if the review does not resolve a difference of opinion, the provider may then submit a written appeal to the plan’s appeals department.

The order matters. In a plan with that rule, filing the appeal first can close the door to the call. Our guide to appealing a prior authorization denial covers the appeal side, including deadlines, and the prior authorization basics explain how requests are built in the first place.

How can the office prepare for the call?

The clinician leads the clinical conversation. Staff can make sure the clinician has what they need:

  1. The denial letter, with the date, the reason and the criteria or guideline the plan cited. The Blue Shield Promise policy says denial communications to providers should include the reasons, a description of the criteria or guidelines used, and the clinical reasons for the decision.
  2. The original request, so the clinician can see exactly what the plan saw.
  3. Records that answer the reason: visit notes, results, treatments already tried.
  4. At least three open dates and times for the clinician. Some Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan request instructions ask for at least three, and plans set their own scheduling blocks.
  5. The name and phone number of the plan physician or contact, if the letter provides them.

Afterward, record the date, who took part, what was said and what happens next. If a reversal is promised, ask for it in writing.

Where Clinicrung fits

Clinicrung is being built to help with the administrative side of authorizations: tracking denied requests, flagging the date a peer-to-peer window closes, and gathering the documents your staff choose for the clinician to review. It is designed so your team stays in control and makes the judgment calls. It is not built yet. Start your free trial to help shape it.

This article is general information, not medical, legal or billing advice. Peer-to-peer and appeal rules differ by plan, contract and state, so read the denial notice and confirm details with the payer or your compliance advisor.