All guides

Referral vs prior authorization: what clinics need to know

A referral and a prior authorization are different things. A referral is an order from a patient’s primary care doctor to see a specialist or get a service. A prior authorization is a decision by the health plan that a service is medically necessary. Some visits need one, some need both, and some need neither, so a clinic has to check each plan.

What is a referral?

HealthCare.gov defines a referral as a written order from your primary care doctor for you to see a specialist or get certain medical services. The same entry notes that some HMO plans require a referral before a patient can see anyone other than the primary care doctor, and that the plan may not pay for services received without one.

So a referral comes from a clinician, and it is tied to how the plan routes care. It does two jobs at once: it hands the patient to another office, and in some plans it is a coverage requirement.

What is a prior authorization?

HealthCare.gov defines preauthorization as a decision by your health insurer or plan that a health care service, treatment plan, prescription drug or durable medical equipment is medically necessary. It is sometimes called prior authorization, prior approval or precertification. The plan may require it for certain services before the patient receives them, except in an emergency. The entry also says it is not a promise that the plan will cover the cost.

So a prior authorization comes from the plan, not from a doctor. For more detail, see our guide to what prior authorization is.

How do they differ side by side?

Referral Prior authorization
Who issues it The patient’s primary care doctor The health plan
What it says Send this patient to a specialist or service This service is medically necessary
Main purpose Route care and, in some plans, meet a coverage rule Approve a service before it happens
Typical trigger Plan type, such as an HMO or POS plan The service, drug or equipment on the plan’s list
Guarantee of payment? Not stated; HealthCare.gov only says the plan may not pay without one No, per the HealthCare.gov definition above

Which plan types require which?

Plan type is the first thing to check, but it is not the last.

  • HMO. For Medicare Advantage plans, Medicare.gov says that in most cases, you have to get a referral to use a specialist in HMO plans. Certain services, such as yearly mammograms, do not need one. The same page tells members to follow plan rules, including getting prior approval for a certain service when the plan requires it. So a patient in this kind of plan can be subject to both a referral rule and a prior approval rule.
  • POS. HealthCare.gov’s plan types page says POS plans require a referral from the primary care doctor to see a specialist.
  • PPO. On the same page, a PPO member can see out-of-network providers without a referral for an additional cost. For Medicare Advantage PPO plans, Medicare.gov’s PPO page answers “No” to whether a member must get a referral to see a specialist. That page is about referrals only, so do not assume a PPO patient needs no approval for a given service. Ask the plan.

Rules can differ by plan and can change, so check with the payer. The plan type tells you what to expect, but the patient’s own plan decides.

How can a clinic check before the visit?

Treat the check as a short routine for every referred or specialist visit.

  1. Verify coverage first. Confirm the plan is active and which plan type it is. Our insurance verification checklist covers the steps.
  2. Ask about the referral. Does this plan require a referral for this specialist or service? Who must enter it, and does the receiving office need a reference number?
  3. Ask about prior authorization. Is this service on the plan’s list? Use the payer’s portal or provider line and write down the answer, date and reference number.
  4. Check the network. The plan types page says a PPO member can see out-of-network providers for an additional cost, so confirm the receiving office is in network.
  5. Record both answers. Put “referral: required, entered” or “prior authorization: not required, per portal” in the patient’s file, so the next person does not repeat the call.
  6. Follow up. Prior authorization is not a promise of payment, so keep tracking until the visit happens and the report returns. See our guide to referral management.

Skipping these checks can be costly. HealthCare.gov warns that the plan may not pay for services received without a required referral, and the clinic is left with calls and resubmissions to sort it out. Asking both questions before the visit is the simplest way to avoid that.

Do the electronic standards treat them the same?

On paper, yes. CMS’s list of adopted HIPAA standards and operating rules shows the same standard, ASC X12N 278 Version 5010, for both referral certification and for prior authorization and referrals, with a standard compliance date of January 1, 2012. Ask each payer how it wants these requests sent, since the method can differ.

Where Clinicrung fits

Clinicrung is being built to run the routine part of this check for independent clinics: look up whether a referral or prior authorization is needed, track the request, and flag the ones that stall, while your staff handle exceptions and decisions. Join the waitlist.

This guide is general information, not medical, legal or billing advice. Plan rules differ and change, so confirm requirements with each payer and check with your compliance advisor.